Stuffed Pepper Jack-o-Lanterns: A Spooky & Delicious Halloween Dinner Idea

Halloween isn’t just about candy—it’s also about the dinner table. If you’re looking for Halloween dinner ideas that make kids giggle, adults smile, and still taste downright delicious, let me introduce you to Stuffed Pepper Jack-o-Lanterns.

These are exactly what they sound like: orange bell peppers carved into little jack-o’-lanterns, filled with a hearty, flavorful stuffing of rice, beef, beans, veggies, and cheese. Imagine your favorite stuffed bell peppers got invited to a costume party—that’s what’s happening here.

They’re festive, spooky, and yes, a full meal tucked inside a carved pepper. Whether you need Halloween party recipes, a clever twist on spooky dinner recipes, or just a fun Halloween recipe for kids, this one checks every box.

Why These Halloween Stuffed Peppers Are the Perfect Dinner

This recipe started as a way to use up leftover peppers and rice that were hanging out in my fridge. One day, I carved a face into a pepper on a whim, stuffed it, baked it, and boom—the Jack-o’-Lantern recipe was born.

Here’s why I keep making them every year:

• Customizable – Swap the meat for chicken, turkey, or go full vegetarian with beans and quinoa.
  
• Kid-friendly – Let the kids carve the faces; they’ll be way more excited to eat what they made.
  
• Minimal cleanup – One pan for the filling, one baking dish, done.
  
• Perfect for leftovers – Rice, veggies, or shredded meat you already cooked? Throw them in.
  

It’s one of those festive fall meals that’s equal parts fun and practical. And unlike half the other Halloween-themed foods out there, this one actually tastes good.

Ingredients for Festive Jack-o’-Lantern Recipes

You don’t need a cauldron for this one—just simple pantry staples.

Ingredient	Amount	Notes
Orange bell peppers	4 large	Carved into jack-o’-lanterns
Cooked rice	1 cup	White, brown, or leftover rice
Ground beef	½ lb	Or substitute with chicken/turkey
Black beans	½ cup	Drained
Corn	½ cup	Canned or fresh
Diced tomatoes	½ cup	Drained well
Cheddar cheese	½ cup	Shredded (or mozzarella for a gooier melt)
Cumin	½ tsp	Warm spice kick
Chili powder	½ tsp	Flavor depth
Salt & pepper	To taste	Season as you go
Olive oil	1–2 tbsp	For brushing peppers

This is a classic ground beef stuffing with a Tex-Mex vibe, but you can pivot in any direction you like.

Why This Recipe Works

• Stuffed bell peppers = edible bowls. They keep everything contained while infusing flavor.
  
• Carved faces act like steam vents. Instead of soggy peppers, you get a nice tender-but-firm texture.
  
• Rice stuffed peppers bring bulk and structure.
  
• Ground beef stuffing adds richness and keeps the dish hearty.
  
• Cheese stuffed peppers—well, do I need to explain? Gooey cheese binds everything together.

Step-by-Step Guide to Making Spooky Dinner Recipes

Step 1: Carve the Peppers

• Slice the tops off your orange bell peppers. Keep those lids—you’ll want them for presentation later.
  
• Scoop out the seeds and membranes.
  
• Carve little jack-o’-lantern faces into the sides. Nothing fancy—triangles for eyes, maybe a toothy grin. (Tip: don’t go too big or the filling will fall out.)
  
• Lightly brush inside and outside with olive oil.

Step 2: Make the Filling

• In a skillet, brown the ground beef. Season with cumin, chili powder, salt, and pepper.
  
• Toss in the beans, corn, and diced tomatoes. Stir well.
  
• Add the rice and half the cheese. Mix until everything’s combined and melty.
  
• Taste, adjust seasoning. This is key—don’t stuff until it tastes great.

Step 3: Fill the Peppers

• Spoon the filling into each carved pepper.
  
• Press it down gently—you want it snug but not so tight that the pepper cracks.

Step 4: Bake

• Arrange peppers upright in a baking dish.
  
• Brush the outside with a little more olive oil (prevents drying).
  
• Bake at 375°F for 25 minutes.

Step 5: Serve

• Let them cool for 5 minutes.
  
• Place the “lids” back on top.
  
• Serve warm with extra cheese, sour cream, or hot sauce.

That’s it—you’ve got Halloween stuffed peppers that look like they came straight from a spooky Pinterest board.

Common Mistakes (and How to Avoid Them)

• Not draining ingredients – Beans and tomatoes need to be drained or the filling turns watery.
  
• Overfilling – Too much stuffing = cracked peppers.
  
• Carving too shallow – If you barely cut the skin, the faces disappear while baking.
  
• Skipping oil – Brushing with oil keeps peppers from drying out and gives them a nice shine.

What to Serve with Fun Halloween Recipes for Kids

These peppers make a complete meal, but if you’re serving a crowd or making them part of a spooky dinner recipe spread, here are some pairing ideas:

• Tortilla chips & guacamole (always a win).
  
• Roasted sweet potatoes with cinnamon.
  
• Autumn dinner ideas like kale salad with apple vinaigrette.
  
• Soup or chili for that cozy fall vibe.

Leftovers & Storage

• Store: Airtight container, up to 3 days in the fridge.
  
• Reheat: Best in the oven (350°F for 15 minutes). Keeps peppers firm.
  
• Microwave: Works in a pinch, but peppers get soft.
  
• Freeze: Yes—bake first, then wrap tightly and freeze up to 2 months.

Halloween & Themed Recipes

If you’re planning a whole spread of Halloween-themed food, these recipes pair perfectly with your Stuffed Pepper Jack-o-Lanterns:

• Serve alongside spooky Halloween Monster Meatball Sliders for a complete festive dinner.
  
• Pair with some fun Halloween Rice Krispies for dessert.
  
• Set the spooky table with Halloween Breadstick Bones on the side.
  
• Add extra creepiness with these Halloween Skull Potatoes.
  
• Balance the savory with sweet Mummy Meatballs for a full Halloween-themed spread.
  
• Baked Cheese Mummies are a fun snack addition to your spooky pepper dinner.

FAQ: Stuffed Pepper Jack-o-Lanterns

Final Encouragement

So here’s the deal: these Stuffed Pepper Jack-o-Lanterns aren’t just a gimmick—they’re actually delicious. They’re a mix of hearty rice stuffed peppers, cheesy goodness, and just enough spooky flair to make them the star of your Halloween party recipes.

If you’re hunting for spooky food ideas that double as dinner, this is it. Carve, stuff, bake, and then sit back and watch everyone’s faces when they see a grinning jack-o’-lantern on their plate.

Make them once, and I promise—they’ll become one of your go-to Halloween dinner ideas. Now grab those orange bell peppers, carve some faces, and let’s get cooking.

Want more festive fall meals and seasonal recipes? Check out my Pinterest page for more inspiration.

This is the Halloween dinner I want to eat.

Print