Pumpkin Pudding Recipe: 5 Simple Steps for Creamy Comfort

Jump to Recipe

Pumpkin pudding is one of those desserts that feels like home. It’s creamy, warm with spices, and has that nostalgic “holiday hug” baked right into every spoonful. I grew up with a grandmother who made it every fall, and let me tell you—by the time the pudding hit the table, it never lasted more than a day.

The best part? You don’t need a pastry degree to make it. With some pumpkin puree, a handful of spices, and a little patience at the stove, you’ll have a silky pumpkin pudding recipe that works just as well for a cozy weeknight treat as it does for a holiday dinner. And here’s the kicker—it’s flexible. You can use canned pumpkin or homemade pumpkin puree, swap whole milk for half-and-half or evaporated milk, even go dairy-free if that’s your thing.

Let’s dive in.

Why Pumpkin Pudding Deserves a Place on Your Table

Pumpkin pudding is like the underrated cousin of bread pudding or sticky toffee pudding. Those desserts get all the attention, but pumpkin pudding? It’s simple, deeply comforting, and just as worthy of your dessert table.

It shines in the fall, sure—the scent of ground cinnamon and nutmeg practically screams autumn—but don’t box it in. It’s light enough to make in spring, cozy enough for winter, and works beautifully as a chilled summer dessert.

And here’s an idea: pair it with other pumpkin favorites. Think pumpkin cheesecake, pumpkin chocolate chip muffins, or even pistachio pudding cookies. A spread like that, and you’ve basically declared yourself the pumpkin king or queen of the neighborhood.

Ingredients That Make the Difference

Here’s where the magic really happens. Each ingredient in a pumpkin pudding recipe does some heavy lifting. Let’s break it down:

Pumpkin Puree

Canned pumpkin is consistent—smooth, reliable, and always ready to go.
Homemade pumpkin puree gives you a fresher, lighter flavor, though it can be a bit more watery (just strain it if needed).

Brown Sugar

Adds molasses depth and warmth that white sugar just can’t match.

Cornstarch

This is your thickener. Without it, you’d end up with pumpkin soup instead of pudding.

Whole Milk, Half-and-Half, or Evaporated Milk

Whole milk: Balanced creaminess.
Half-and-half: Richer, fuller body.
Evaporated milk: Extra creamy with a slightly caramelized edge.

(Pro tip: if you want a lighter pudding, swap in dairy-free milk alternatives like almond, oat, or coconut milk. Just know the texture will be a little thinner.)

Eggs for Pudding

Eggs are what give pudding its silky structure. Skip them, and you’ll need more cornstarch to make up the difference.

Spices

This is where most people mess up—they use that sad, stale jar of pumpkin spice from three Thanksgivings ago. Don’t do that. Fresh ground cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, and ginger make all the difference. Or, if you want convenience, a fresh jar of pumpkin spice works too.

Vanilla Extract

Stirred in at the end, vanilla ties everything together with a warm sweetness.

Ingredient Substitutions at a Glance

Ingredient	Standard Option	Substitution	Flavor/Texture Impact
Pumpkin puree	Canned pumpkin	Homemade pumpkin puree	Fresher, lighter, less dense
Whole milk	Half-and-half	Evaporated milk	Richer, creamier
Dairy milk	Almond/Oat/Soy	Coconut milk	Thinner, subtle flavor shift
Brown sugar	Light or dark	Coconut sugar	Slightly caramel-like

Steps for a Smooth and Creamy Pumpkin Pudding

Here’s how you nail it. And don’t skip steps—this is pudding, not a dump-and-stir casserole.

1. Combine the Dry Ingredients

In a saucepan, whisk together:

Brown sugar
Cornstarch
A pinch of salt
Your spices (ground cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, cloves—or pumpkin spice if you’re keeping it easy)

This step is key. Mixing the cornstarch with sugar first keeps it from clumping when you add the liquids.

2. Add the Wet Ingredients

Whisk in:

Whole milk (or half-and-half, or evaporated milk if you want that richness)
Pumpkin puree (canned or homemade pumpkin puree)
Eggs for pudding (one or two, depending on how custardy you like it)

Smooth is the name of the game here—no streaks, no lumps.

3. Cook the Pudding

Medium heat. Stir constantly. Don’t walk away. After about 6–8 minutes, the mixture will start to bubble and thicken. You’re looking for a glossy, thick texture that coats the back of a spoon.

(Most people crank the heat here. Big mistake. Too hot, and you’ll scramble the eggs. Low and steady wins.)

4. Add Vanilla

Take the pan off the heat and stir in a splash of vanilla extract. That little detail makes the pudding sing.

5. Pour into Ramekins

Spoon the pudding into individual ramekins or serving bowls. (If you’re going family-style, a big dish works too, but there’s something special about your own personal pudding cup.)

6. Chill or Serve Warm

Chilled version: Press plastic wrap directly onto the surface to prevent a skin from forming. Chill at least 2 hours.
Warm version: Serve straight away, comfort-food style.

7. Garnish and Serve

This is where you can have fun:

Whipped cream with a dusting of pumpkin spice
Crushed gingersnaps or graham crackers
Toasted pecans or walnuts
Even a drizzle of caramel if you’re feeling fancy

Baked pumpkin pudding in white ramekins with cinnamon topping

Serving and Storage Ideas

Pumpkin pudding is versatile—you can dress it up or keep it humble.

Serving Suggestions: Whipped cream and crushed cookies are classic. Cinnamon dusting makes it elegant.
Pairings: Serve alongside pumpkin chocolate chip muffins, easy pumpkin scones, or pistachio pudding cookies for a full dessert spread.
Storage: Keep covered in the fridge for up to 2 days. (Good luck with that—it rarely lasts that long.)

Make-ahead tip: This pudding is a lifesaver if you’re hosting. Make it the night before, and all you need to do is garnish before serving.

If this pumpkin pudding recipe got you in the mood for more pumpkin goodness, I’ve got plenty of other treats waiting for you:

Looking for savory balance? Try my Pumpkin desserts for fall — yes, pumpkin works in chili too.
Craving a classic bake? Check out my Moist and spiced pumpkin coffee cake.
Want something indulgent? My Classic pumpkin spice cake with cream cheese frosting is always a hit.
Need a gluten-free option? Try these Gluten-free pumpkin squares.
Looking for a healthier snack? My Healthy pumpkin oatmeal bars will keep you fueled and satisfied.

These recipes pair beautifully with pumpkin pudding or work as stand-alone stars for your fall table.

Here’s the truth: this pumpkin pudding disappears faster than I can make it. Every single time. It’s that comforting. Pair it with some pumpkin scones, light a candle, and suddenly you’ve got yourself the coziest fall evening imaginable.

I want you to try this recipe, tweak it if you like, and make it your own. Go extra heavy on the spices if you’re into that. Try it dairy-free. Layer it into a trifle with whipped cream and cookies. Whatever you do, share it—and let me know how it turns out.

Because this? This is the pumpkin pudding I want to eat.

FAQs About Pumpkin Pudding Recipe

Can I use canned pumpkin instead of homemade pumpkin puree?

Definitely. Canned pumpkin is consistent and easy, while homemade pumpkin puree is fresher but less dense.

Can I make pumpkin pudding without eggs?

Yes—just up the cornstarch and use dairy-free milk alternatives. It’ll be slightly less rich, but still creamy.

Is evaporated milk a good substitute?

Absolutely. It gives the pudding a creamier, slightly caramelized flavor.

How do I keep my pudding from turning lumpy?

Whisk constantly and cook gently. Don’t let the heat run too high.

Can I make pumpkin pudding ahead of time?

Yes—it keeps up to 2 days in the fridge. Just cover it well so the top doesn’t dry out.

Conclusion + Call to Action

Pumpkin pudding is comfort in a bowl—smooth, spiced, and endlessly flexible. Whether you use canned pumpkin or homemade pumpkin puree, whole milk or dairy-free milk alternatives, this recipe works. It’s easy, adaptable, and downright delicious.

So grab your whisk, pick your spices, and make a batch. Share it with family, friends, or just keep it all for yourself (I won’t judge).

And when you do? Let me know how it turned out. Did you go classic, or did you add your own spin? Drop your version in the comments—I’d love to hear it.

If you’re looking for more cozy desserts and inspiration, check out my Pinterest page where I share recipes, tips, and plenty of pumpkin love.

This is the pumpkin pudding recipe you’ll come back to again and again.

Pumpkin Pudding Recipe: Creamy, Spiced, and Comforting

Why Pumpkin Pudding Deserves a Place on Your Table

Table of Contents